What Iran’s 1979 Revolution Should Teach Every American About Dangerous Political Alliances
From the Craig Bushon Show Media Team
When Dr. Sheila Nazarian stood before an audience at the 2026 Christians United for Israel Summit, she delivered a warning that deserves far more attention than it has received. Nazarian, an Iranian-American surgeon whose family fled Iran following the Islamic Revolution, was not simply offering another political opinion. She was speaking about a country her family once called home and the consequences of a revolution that promised change but ultimately delivered a different form of oppression.
Her warning was unmistakable: “I have seen this movie before, and I know how it ends.”
Those words should concern Americans regardless of their political affiliation, religious beliefs, or opinions about the Middle East. Because what happened in Iran in 1979 was not simply a religious revolution. It was also a lesson in political manipulation, competing ideologies, and what happens when movements with fundamentally different objectives join forces to overthrow a common adversary.
And when we examine certain political alliances emerging in America today, there are some uncomfortable similarities worth discussing.
The Revolution That Changed Everything
In 1979, Iran’s Shah, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, lost power following years of growing opposition to his government. The resistance was not composed of one unified political movement. It included religious conservatives, Marxists, socialists, secular nationalists, students, intellectuals, and ordinary Iranians who wanted political change.
The Shah’s government had a documented record of political repression, including imprisonment and torture of dissidents. Those grievances were legitimate. But the existence of an oppressive government does not automatically mean that the people seeking to replace it share a commitment to freedom.
That distinction would become devastatingly clear.
Among the opposition were leftist organizations that believed Iran needed a socialist or Marxist political transformation. At the same time, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and his supporters envisioned a government built around Islamic religious authority.
These were not minor disagreements over economic policy or government spending. They were fundamentally different visions of society, individual liberty, and the relationship between religion and the state.
Yet they found common ground in their opposition to the Shah and the political order he represented.
Some leftist groups believed cooperation with Khomeini would help advance their revolutionary ambitions. Others opposed the clerics from early on. The movement was never as unified as it sometimes appears in hindsight.
But one critical mistake made by some revolutionaries was assuming that cooperation against a common enemy would somehow lead to a government that respected their own beliefs.
History proved otherwise.
When Yesterday’s Allies Became Today’s Enemies
After the Shah’s government collapsed in February 1979, Khomeini and his supporters began consolidating political authority.
The consequences for individual freedoms appeared almost immediately.
Within weeks, Iranian women were protesting new restrictions on their rights, including demands that women working in government offices observe Islamic dress requirements. On March 8, 1979, thousands took to the streets in opposition.
The revolution that many believed would create a more just society was already restricting the freedoms of people who had participated in the struggle against the monarchy.
The universities soon became another battleground.
In 1980, Iran launched what became known as its Cultural Revolution. Universities were closed, professors and students were expelled, and educational institutions were reorganized to conform to the new government’s political and religious ideology.
The Iran Human Rights Documentation Center has documented how the authorities targeted leftist student organizations and removed individuals whose beliefs conflicted with the Islamic Republic’s objectives.
By 1983, even the Tudeh Party, a communist organization that had supported Khomeini, faced widespread arrests and suppression.
Think about the significance of that sequence.
Political organizations that once cooperated with the revolutionary leadership were eventually treated as threats to the very government they had helped bring to power.
Some had believed they could influence the revolution from within. Others believed their cooperation would protect their place in the new political system.
Instead, they discovered that sharing an opponent did not mean sharing a future.
And the Iranian people paid the price.
The Alliance Americans Should Be Examining
This is where Nazarian’s warning becomes especially relevant to the United States.
In recent years, particularly following the October 7, 2023, terrorist attacks against Israel and the war in Gaza, Americans have witnessed political activism bringing together people with very different ideological and cultural beliefs.
Among them are progressive organizations that champion women’s equality, LGBTQ rights, secular government, and freedom of expression. Some operate alongside groups or activists whose political and religious beliefs differ sharply from those principles.
Now, we need to make an important distinction.
Supporting the rights of Palestinian civilians is not the same as supporting Hamas. Criticizing Israeli government policy is not inherently antisemitic. And practicing Islam does not mean supporting the imposition of religious law on others.
Americans have every constitutional right to engage in peaceful protest, advocate for Palestinian rights, criticize governments, and practice their religion.
But those freedoms should not prevent us from asking difficult questions about the political movements that emerge from these alliances.
What happens when an organization that claims to defend women’s rights overlooks an allied movement’s restrictions on women? What happens when activists who demand freedom of expression excuse the suppression of dissent by movements they consider politically useful?
And what happens when opposition to one government or policy becomes more important than examining the governing philosophy of those who might replace it?
These are not questions of race or religion. They are questions about political power, individual liberty, and intellectual consistency.
It is perfectly reasonable to oppose civilian suffering while also rejecting Hamas’s authoritarian ideology and attacks on civilians. Those positions are not contradictory.
What should concern us is the willingness of some activists to overlook authoritarian behavior simply because it comes from someone they regard as an ally.
That is one of the lessons Iran’s revolution offers.
The Enemy of My Enemy Is Not Always My Friend
There is an old political calculation that has influenced conflicts throughout history: the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
Sometimes cooperation between groups with different beliefs is necessary and productive. America’s own political system depends on compromise.
But there is a tremendous difference between compromising over public policy and cooperating with movements whose ultimate objectives would eliminate the freedoms that make compromise possible.
Consider the contradiction.
A movement cannot genuinely claim to defend freedom of religion while advocating a government that coerces religious observance. It cannot consistently defend women’s equality while excusing a political system that denies women equal rights. And it cannot champion free expression while supporting the imprisonment of people for criticizing those in power.
The problem is not simply that different ideologies sometimes cooperate.
The problem arises when people ignore those contradictions because they believe a shared political objective is more important than the principles they claim to represent.
That was a critical failure among some of the political factions involved in Iran’s revolution.
We should be willing to recognize the same danger wherever it appears, regardless of whether it comes from the political left, the political right, or a religious movement.
Why America’s Constitution Matters
Unlike Iran in 1979, the United States operates under a constitutional republic designed to limit government authority and protect individual liberties.
Our founding framework does not depend on every American sharing the same religious or political beliefs.
In fact, it recognizes that Americans will disagree.
The First Amendment protects freedom of religion, speech, the press, peaceful assembly, and the right to petition the government. Our constitutional system also establishes limits on governmental power and provides mechanisms for holding public officials accountable.
That is precisely why the Constitution is so important.
It protects the rights of Christians, Jews, Muslims, atheists, and everyone else. It allows citizens to debate socialism, capitalism, religious values, and political reform without requiring everyone to accept the same ideology.
But it does not authorize a political or religious movement to strip other Americans of their constitutional rights simply because that movement gains influence.
There is a fundamental distinction between freely practicing one’s religion and using the coercive power of government to require others to practice it.
There is also a fundamental distinction between advocating political change through constitutional means and seeking power for the purpose of eliminating constitutional protections.
Americans should understand those distinctions before lending support to any political movement, including movements that claim to be acting in the name of justice, equality, or national renewal.
Our Constitution cannot guarantee that every political leader will act responsibly. That requires informed voters, independent institutions, accountability, and citizens who understand what their government is authorized to do.
Constitutional rights are most vulnerable when citizens become willing to sacrifice someone else’s freedoms to advance their own political objectives.
What We Should Be Teaching the Next Generation
One of the greatest failures in political education is treating historical revolutions as simple stories of oppressed people rising against oppressive rulers.
Sometimes that is how they begin.
But the more important question is what happens afterward.
Who gains power? What laws are enacted? What happens to the opposition? Are women freer? Are religious minorities protected? Can journalists criticize the new government? Can citizens peacefully remove their leaders?
Those questions reveal far more about the success or failure of a political revolution than the slogans used to organize it.
Iran’s experience deserves serious study because its history demonstrates how a movement involving competing political philosophies ultimately produced a government that suppressed many of those who had participated in the revolution.
The warning should not be limited to one religion, country, or political ideology.
Any movement that concentrates power while treating individual rights as obstacles deserves scrutiny.
And any coalition that refuses to address fundamental disagreements about liberty and government authority should be challenged before it gains that power.
America Still Has a Choice
Dr. Sheila Nazarian’s testimony matters because her family experienced the consequences of a revolution that fundamentally transformed their country.
But the lesson Americans should take from her experience is not that every unfamiliar political movement represents the next Iranian Revolution.
That would be an exaggeration, and exaggeration weakens an otherwise important historical warning.
The lesson is that political intentions must be judged against political objectives, and political objectives must be judged against what happens when those seeking power actually obtain it.
We should never be so consumed by opposition to one political party, one elected official, or one foreign government that we stop examining the people and ideologies with whom we are aligning ourselves.
For Americans who believe in faith, family, individual responsibility, national sovereignty, and the constitutional principles upon which this republic was established, that responsibility is especially important.
We should also recognize that the protection of those principles includes defending the constitutional rights of Americans with whom we strongly disagree.
Because the moment we decide that constitutional protections should apply only to those who share our political or religious beliefs, we begin abandoning the very system we claim to defend.
The 1979 Iranian Revolution provides a historical warning about what can happen when incompatible political movements cooperate to obtain power without an enduring commitment to individual liberty.
America does not have to follow that path.
But avoiding it requires more than patriotic slogans. It requires historical understanding, political accountability, and citizens who are willing to question the motives and objectives of everyone seeking authority over them.
That is how a free republic protects itself.
And that is why Nazarian’s warning deserves to be heard.
The truth is not hate speech. And learning from history is not fear mongering. It is one of the responsibilities of a free people determined to remain free.
Disclaimer: This article presents historical analysis and political opinion. It distinguishes lawful religious belief, peaceful political participation, and advocacy for Palestinian civilians from support for authoritarian movements or coercive government. Political organizations and individuals should be evaluated on their documented actions, stated objectives, and respect for constitutional rights.







